Kitsilano speaks up: 26-storey development proposal raises serious questions
2158–2170 West 1st Avenue, Vancouver — What is being proposed, why residents are concerned, and what could happen next?
A community in Kitsilano is organizing and speaking out about a proposed change to a development at 2158–2170 West 1st Avenue.
Residents have questions about the size of the proposed building, the reduction in rental homes, the addition of hotel rooms and the impact on a neighbourhood that is already experiencing the pressures of growth.
This is not simply a question of whether Vancouver needs development. We do need housing. We need rental housing, and we need homes that people can afford.
But there is already an approved development for this property. So why is that plan being changed, and who benefits from the proposed changes?
Let's look at what has happened and what is at stake.
1. There was already an approved development
On June 2, 2026, the City enacted zoning for a 20-storey rental building at this location.
The approved proposal included:
- 185 secured rental homes.
- Approximately 20% of the residential floor area as below-market rental housing.
- Commercial space at street level.
- A building approximately 64.7 metres (212 feet) high.
That was the approved plan.
2. A very different proposal has now been submitted
A new application, submitted in August 2026, asks the City to amend that approval.
The revised proposal includes:
- A 26-storey building, approximately 92 metres (301 feet) high.
- 121 rental homes.
- 24 below-market rental homes.
- 99 hotel rooms.
- Five underground parking levels.
- Commercial space at street level.
That is 64 fewer rental homes and 10 fewer below-market homes than the numbers in the previously approved plan, while adding 99 hotel rooms and six additional storeys.
The City says the new application seeks height and density beyond existing Broadway Plan provisions. It also says hotel use is not contemplated under current policy.
These are significant changes. Residents deserve to understand why they are being proposed.
3. Ten concerns the community deserves answers to
1. Why are there fewer rental homes?
Vancouver is in a housing crisis. The previously approved plan provided 185 secured rental homes. The new proposal provides 121. Why should the community accept a reduction of 64 rental homes?
2. Why are there fewer below-market homes?
The previous proposal listed 34 below-market homes. The new application lists 24. The City describes both proposals as providing 20% of residential floor area as below-market housing, but the number of homes is lower. Residents deserve a clear explanation of what that means for actual affordability.
3. Why add 99 hotel rooms?
Why is hotel accommodation being proposed on a site where the previous approval was for rental housing? Residents are entitled to ask whether this is the best use of the property when so many people are struggling to find a home.
4. Why make the building six storeys taller?
The proposed height increases from approximately 64.7 metres to 92 metres. That is a substantial change. What does it mean for the surrounding streets, homes, businesses and public spaces?
5. Why depart from the Broadway Plan?
The City acknowledges that the application seeks additional height and density beyond existing policy provisions and includes a hotel use not contemplated under current policy. If exceptions can be considered, residents should be told why this proposal deserves one.
6. What about sunlight and shadows?
Residents have raised questions about the effect on nearby streets, public spaces and the beach area. The submitted shadow studies include March, June and September. What about the winter months, when daylight is already limited?
7. Can local infrastructure handle the change?
Traffic, parking, deliveries, pedestrian safety, cycling routes and local services all matter. Residents are asking whether the neighbourhood has the infrastructure to support a development of this scale.
8. What happens to existing tenants?
There are two purpose-built rental buildings on the site. The City says tenant protections apply, including assistance under its Tenant Relocation and Protection Policy and a right of first refusal to return to the completed development for eligible tenants. Residents deserve clear information about how those protections will work if the project changes.
9. Why change the approval so soon?
The original zoning was enacted on June 2, 2026. The new application followed in August. People have a reasonable right to ask why an approved rental housing plan is now being replaced with a proposal containing fewer rental homes and a hotel.
10. Is the public being given a meaningful opportunity to participate?
People need to know about proposals that could change their neighbourhood. They need accessible information, enough time to understand it and a genuine opportunity to raise concerns. Public consultation should be more than a notice that people may never see.
4. What is the community doing?
Residents are organizing, sharing information and encouraging their neighbours to get involved.
On November 12, CityNews reported on Kitsilano residents speaking out about the proposal. Their concerns include the reduction in rental housing, the hotel, the height of the building and the pressures on the surrounding neighbourhood.
A community petition has also been created:
Keep Kitsilano Liveable: Oppose Rezoning at 2158–2170 West 1st Avenue.
This is an opportunity for people to show that they are paying attention and that neighbourhood concerns should matter in decisions about development.
5. What happens next?
The City opened a public question-and-answer period from November 18 to December 1, 2026.
Residents can submit questions through the City's Shape Your City page. The City says the comment form will remain open after the question period ends, and people can also contact the rezoning planner.
City planning staff will review the application, assess it against applicable policies and consider public feedback. Staff will prepare a report with their analysis and recommendation.
Ultimately, City Council makes the decision.
The application is not automatically approved just because it has been submitted.
6. What could happen either way?
There are important differences between the possible outcomes.
If Council refuses the new amendment:
The existing zoning remains in place. That means the owner could proceed with the previously approved 20-storey development containing 185 secured rental homes.
However, there is an important qualification. The City says it cannot require the owner to begin construction by a particular date or finish by a deadline. The timing remains the owner's decision, subject to permits and other requirements.
Refusing the amendment would preserve the existing approval, but it would not guarantee when construction would begin.
If Council approves the new proposal:
The property could proceed under the amended zoning for a 26-storey building with 121 rental homes, 24 below-market homes and 99 hotel rooms, subject to the necessary permits and requirements.
Council could also make changes:
Council has the authority to consider amendments and conditions rather than simply accepting or refusing the application as submitted.
That is why public participation matters. Residents need to make their concerns known before Council makes its decision.
7. How can you help?
If you live in Kitsilano, work in the area or care about Vancouver's future, take a few minutes to learn about the proposal.
- Read the City's application information.
- Submit questions and comments to the City.
- Sign and share the community petition.
- Talk to neighbours who may not know about the proposal.
- Ask why the approved plan for 185 rental homes is being replaced with one containing 121.
- Ask Council to explain why additional height, density and hotel rooms are being considered.
City information and public feedback:
https://www.shapeyourcity.ca/2158-2170-w-1-ave-3
Community petition:
https://www.change.org/p/keep-kitsilano-liveable-oppose-rezoning-at-2158-2170-west-1st-avenue
The bigger picture: who is Vancouver being built for?
Vancouver needs development, but development should serve the people who live here, not just the interests of property owners and investors.
There was already an approved plan for 185 secured rental homes at this location. Now the community is being asked to consider a much taller building with fewer rental homes and 99 hotel rooms.
Residents are not wrong to question that change.
The City has a choice. Council can refuse the amendment and leave the existing approval in place, approve the new proposal, or consider changes. Whatever happens, the people who live in this neighbourhood should have a meaningful voice in the decision.
I support residents who are organizing, asking questions and encouraging their neighbours to participate. Speaking up is not being against housing or against change. It is asking for responsible planning, transparency and accountability.
A neighbourhood is more than a development site. It is the people who live there, the businesses they support, the streets they walk and cycle, and the public spaces they share.
If we want livable communities, we need to pay attention to the decisions being made about them.
Don't assume someone else will speak up. Read, share, ask questions and have your say.
The decision has not yet been made. The community still has an opportunity to be heard.
Keywords: Kitsilano, Vancouver development, West 1st Avenue, Broadway Plan, rental housing, below-market housing, hotel development, community organizing, public consultation, neighbourhood livability
Hashtags: #Kitsilano #Vancouver #KeepKitsilanoLiveable #RentalHousing #AffordableHousing #BroadwayPlan #ShapeYourCity #CommunityVoices #VancouverDevelopment #NeighbourhoodMatters