we cannot eat applause👏👏👏👏
and we cannot pay rent 🏠🏡🏚🏕😬🤦♀️with compliments.
Mark Carney's $4-billion announcement about Canadian culture sounds impressive. The titles are impressive, too.
The Canada Creative Credit. The Productivity Mega Deduction.
But I want to talk about what this looks like from the other side of the paintbrush.
I am an independent artist. I've been creating, exhibiting, painting murals, photographing, blogging and documenting my work for decades.
And I have a very different perspective on what it takes to make a living as an artist.
The proposed Canada Creative Credit would provide tax relief on up to $45,000 of qualifying annual net business income from original creative artistic work. It is not a $45,000 payment to artists, and the government still has to consult on the details.
That distinction matters enormously.
A tax credit does not create a customer.
It doesn't convince someone to buy an original painting instead of a cheap print. It doesn't make a business owner pay an independent artist fairly. It doesn't provide a studio, a gallery, a place to exhibit, or a home in which to make art.
And what happens when artists are already struggling to sell their work?
I know what that looks like.
I've had family members who never bought my art. I've had friends buy some of my best paintings for very little. I've sold work that I loved, only to find myself without the original pieces I needed to photograph, exhibit and promote my next collection.
I've watched businesses appreciate artwork while expecting artists to practically give it away.
So where exactly is the market that is supposed to support us?
And there is another concern.
When a government introduces a tax measure, there will inevitably be questions about eligibility, verification and possible abuse. But I don't want legitimate independent artists treated as suspects because somebody somewhere might exploit a program.
Don't build a system that makes working artists jump through hoops, then blame the artists when the system needs policing.
We need transparent rules, sensible safeguards and respect for the people actually doing the creative work.
Carney talks about artists making a living from their art. I would love to see that happen.
But here's what I would like him to understand:
- We need affordable places to live.
- We need affordable studios and working spaces.
- We need galleries and exhibition opportunities.
- We need businesses and institutions that purchase original Canadian art at fair prices.
- We need better access to customers.
- We need protection for independent creators and their original work.
- We need people to understand that art is labour, not a hobby that should always be donated.
And please remember that not every artist has a gallery, a manager, a commercial studio, wealthy clients or family money behind them.
Some of us are doing everything ourselves.
I have spent years creating original artwork, murals, photography, online projects and thousands of blog posts. I have built an audience without advertising.
I know what it takes to create. I also know what it takes to try to sell that creation.
A tax deduction doesn't sell a painting. A tax credit doesn't put dinner on the table if nobody buys the work.
I don't want another announcement telling us how valuable Canadian culture is.
I want a country where Canadian artists can actually afford to participate in the culture they help create.
Carney, you have the numbers. But have you listened to the artists who are trying to survive between those numbers?
Because we cannot eat applause.
And we cannot pay rent with compliments.
Who actually benefits when governments announce billions for the creative economy?
1.If art is so valuable to our national identity, why are so many artists struggling to afford basic necessities?
2. Can a tax credit create a market where people simply aren't buying original artwork?
3. Who actually benefits when governments announce billions for the creative economy?
4. Why do we celebrate artists after they become successful but rarely support them while they're struggling?
5. When did we decide that artists should be grateful for exposure instead of being paid for their labour?
6. How many paintings, songs, photographs, books and creative projects have disappeared because their creators couldn't afford to continue?
7. Should independent artists have to become business administrators, marketers and accountants just to qualify for support?
8. What responsibility do businesses, institutions and individuals have to support the artists whose work enriches their communities?
9. How can we protect legitimate artists from exploitation without creating systems that make it harder for them to earn a living?
10. If we cannot afford to house, feed and fairly compensate the people creating Canadian culture, what exactly are we investing in?
#SupportLivingArtists #CanadianArtists #ArtIsWork #PayArtistsFairly #IndependentArtists #CanadianCulture #CreativeEconomy #OriginalArt #ArtistsNeedHomes #ArtMatters



