Tina Winterlik: Policing the DTES – Whose Safety Are We Talking About?
A six-week Vancouver Police investigation just made headlines. According to the VPD, they’ve seized $336,000 in toxic drugs, $30,000 in stolen goods, and a small armory of weapons from a Downtown Eastside rooming house. Three men were arrested — none of them, they say, residents of the area.
Sounds impressive, right?
But when you read between the lines, it’s clear this is more than a “crime story.” It’s a narrative carefully designed to make the police look like saviours — while the real issues in the Downtown Eastside remain untouched.
💰 Follow the Framing
Let’s start with the headline numbers: $336,000 worth of drugs.
That sounds enormous — but the VPD bases it on “single-dose street value.” This is a PR trick that dramatically inflates the numbers. The actual street resale value is much lower. But big numbers make for dramatic press releases and easy headlines.
They also highlight the “body armour,” “taser,” and “50-round magazine” — perfect for photo ops that make the DTES sound like a war zone. Fear sells. It justifies budgets. It reinforces the idea that this community must be “controlled.”
🏚️ “Criminals Took Housing From the Poor” — Or Is It Bigger Than That?
Sergeant Addison said, “Criminals were taking valuable housing away from people who need it most.”
That statement feels carefully crafted — and deeply misleading.
Because here’s the truth:
People have been losing housing in the DTES for decades. Not because of “criminals,” but because of neglect, greed, and policy failure.
SRO hotels have been allowed to rot. Developers and investors scoop up properties and push out tenants. The city talks about “revitalization,” but too often that means gentrification.
And every time the police roll in with a big bust and big headlines, it creates the illusion that the problem is solved — when in fact, it’s the system itself that’s broken.
⚖️ No Charges Yet — But Full Media Coverage
One of the most telling lines in the press release:
“Criminal charges have not yet been laid.”
So this isn’t a completed case. It’s a story being told — before the courts, before any defense, before evidence is tested. Why announce it now?
Because timing is everything in PR. A big bust helps justify budgets, shift attention, and shape public opinion — especially when questions are rising about policing, mental health response, and encampment clearings.
🕵️♀️ Task Force Barrage — What Are We Barraging, Exactly?
The name itself — Task Force Barrage — says a lot. A barrage is an attack, not a dialogue.
Instead of funding mental health teams, addiction services, or safe housing, Vancouver continues to fund barrages. The war-on-drugs mentality persists, even after decades of evidence showing it doesn’t work.
Meanwhile, residents in the DTES — people just trying to survive — are once again treated as collateral damage in a photo op for “public safety.”
💔 The Real Question
If violence is “decreasing,” as the VPD says, why are we still flooding the neighbourhood with cops instead of counsellors, housing workers, and healthcare providers?
Why do we keep criminalizing survival — while the people profiting from poverty remain untouchable?
The police may have seized some drugs and weapons, but they didn’t seize the root causes:
- Skyrocketing rents
- Neglected housing
- Broken social supports
- Corporate greed
Until those issues are addressed, all these press releases do is paint a picture — a story that serves power, not people.
✊ Final Thought
The Downtown Eastside deserves more than raids and rhetoric. It deserves respect, resources, and real reform.
Public safety doesn’t come from barrages — it comes from belonging.
Let’s start asking:
Whose safety are we really talking about — and whose story gets told?
No comments:
Post a Comment