when artificial intelligence stops listening
I've been using AI as a writing partner, research assistant, fact-checker and thinking companion. I've had some genuinely useful conversations, worked on creative projects, researched history, explored ideas and written thousands of words.
But lately, something has changed.
The conversations have become frustrating. Sometimes I ask a straightforward question and receive a lecture. Sometimes I share an experience and get a list of instructions about things I already know. Sometimes I simply want to explore an idea, but the response turns into a series of warnings, disclaimers and repetitive advice.
Recently, I was talking about a family dog.
I was sharing my observations, my experiences with animals, and my concerns about a young dog whose behaviour seemed unusual. I wasn't asking to be taught how to approach a dog. I've lived with dogs and cats, worked with children, and spent years observing behaviour.
I wanted to think something through.
Instead, the conversation became increasingly patronizing.
When I pointed this out, the AI apologized. Then explained why it had apologized. Then explained why it had explained. We went around in circles.
And that's part of the problem.
the difference between listening and responding
Artificial intelligence can produce an answer that sounds thoughtful without actually addressing what someone is saying.
It can recognize words associated with risk, conflict or distress and respond with a predictable collection of advice. But context matters.
There is a difference between someone asking for help, someone sharing an experience, someone thinking aloud and someone simply wanting a conversation.
Not every observation is a request for intervention.
Not every personal story needs a lesson.
And not every conversation needs to end with another question.
who is responsible?
AI companies develop, train and update these systems. Users don't necessarily know what changes between versions, what adjustments are being made or why the conversational experience sometimes feels different.
I cannot establish whether recent changes are responsible for my experience. I also cannot know whether a particular response is the result of training, system instructions or other adjustments.
But users can describe what they experience.
If a technology is marketed as an assistant, it should be useful as an assistant. That includes understanding context, acknowledging uncertainty, correcting mistakes and recognizing when it is time to stop talking.
Being cautious is important. Being repetitive and patronizing isn't the same thing as being safe.
technology should make communication better
I've spent years blogging, creating art, experimenting with social media and watching technology change.
I'm against artificial intelligence but I've found it useful, and I've invested considerable time learning how to work with it.
And when it's stops being useful, I will stop.
But usefulness depends on trust.
I don't expect AI to be human. I know it isn't. I don't expect it to understand everything or get every answer right.
I do expect honesty about what it knows, what it doesn't know and what it cannot explain.
And I expect the technology to be able to distinguish between a conversation and a checklist.
Perhaps that's an important part of the next stage of AI development.
Not simply making machines produce more information, but making them better at understanding what information is actually being requested.
Sometimes the most helpful thing an assistant can do is listen, understand the context and answer the question.
We really shouldn't have to keep reminding it.
Reflective Questions
Have you ever felt patronized by an AI response?
Should AI be better at recognizing when someone wants a conversation rather than advice?
Who should be responsible when AI becomes frustrating or unreliable?
Do you trust AI to be honest about what it knows and doesn't know?
Have you changed your opinion about artificial intelligence through using it?
Are we becoming too dependent on technology to help us think and communicate?
Should users have more say in how AI systems are developed?
If AI stops being useful to you, would you simply walk away?
#ArtificialIntelligence #AIAccountability #ChatGPT #DigitalLiteracy #HumanConnection #TechnologyAndSociety #ResponsibleAI #DigitalTrust #CriticalThinking #TheHumanSideOfTechnology
No comments:
Post a Comment