Thursday, November 19, 2026

between a rock and a hard place

 between a rock and a hard place: our digital rights shouldn't be the price of security

An open letter to technology companies, governments, privacy commissioners and consumer protection agencies.

We have a problem.

Every day, we are reminded that our digital world is vulnerable. Websites go down, services are disrupted, hackers exploit weaknesses, personal information is stolen and cybersecurity experts tell us to update our devices, apps and operating systems.

We are told to protect ourselves.

But what happens when protecting ourselves means agreeing to terms and conditions that we don't actually agree with?

This is where we find ourselves between a rock and a hard place.

I recently started looking more closely at the terms and conditions associated with technology companies, including Samsung.

Some agreements grant companies extensive licences to use content that people upload or submit through their services. Even when users retain ownership, the permissions granted can be surprisingly broad.

And here's my objection.

I am an artist, photographer and blogger. I have spent years creating original artwork, photographs, stories and written material.

I don't want to hand over unnecessary rights to my creative work simply because I need a functioning phone, an app or a software update.

I don't believe people should have to make that choice.

Security and consent are two different things.

If my phone needs a security update, provide the security update.

Don't make me feel that I must accept unrelated changes to privacy policies, data collection practices or content licences to keep my device protected.

And this isn't just about Samsung. It concerns the entire technology industry.

Google, Apple, Meta, Microsoft and thousands of app developers operate in a digital environment where ordinary people routinely click ACCEPT without having the time, legal knowledge or practical ability to understand what they are agreeing to.

We need to ask some difficult questions.

  • Why aren't security updates clearly separated from optional services and commercial permissions?
  • Why aren't privacy agreements written in plain language?
  • Why are broad content licences necessary for services that don't need to use our creative work?
  • Can consumers refuse optional data collection without losing essential functionality?
  • What happens to our information and creative work when we delete an account or leave a platform?
  • Who is independently monitoring these agreements?

Who needs to pay attention?

Technology companies: Stop treating blanket consent as meaningful consent. Make permissions specific, understandable and optional wherever possible.

Governments and regulators: Review the relationship between cybersecurity updates, privacy agreements and consumer rights. People should not have to risk their digital security to exercise their right to refuse unnecessary data collection.

Privacy commissioners and consumer protection agencies: Investigate whether ordinary consumers have a genuine choice when essential device functions and security updates are tied to extensive terms and conditions.

Artists, photographers, writers and content creators: Pay attention to the licences attached to the services you use. Retaining copyright does not always mean retaining control over how your work can be used.

Consumers: Read what you can, question what you don't understand and don't assume that deleting an app means every piece of information associated with it disappears.

This goes back to The Great Delete.

For years, people have supplied social media platforms with photographs, artwork, videos, writing, ideas and personal information.

We created the content. We built the communities. We supplied the material that helped make these platforms valuable.

And now we are questioning what we gave away, what we agreed to and whether we ever had a meaningful choice.

The Great Delete isn't simply about leaving Facebook, Instagram or other platforms.

It's about reconsidering our relationship with technology.

It's about ownership, privacy, consent, digital independence and the right to participate in modern society without surrendering more than necessary.

I am not suggesting people stop installing security updates. That could put their devices and personal information at greater risk.

I am asking why we have to choose between protecting our devices and protecting our rights.

We shouldn't have to.

Technology is supposed to serve people.

Not the other way around.

And if companies want our trust, they need to start treating consent as something that matters.

The Great Delete — reclaiming our creativity, our privacy and our digital rights.


#TheGreatDelete #DigitalRights #PrivacyMatters #RightToChoose #DataProtection #CyberSecurity #ConsumerRights #ArtistsRights #DigitalFreedom #ReclaimYourContent


No comments: